Australian businesses pay ransomware demands more often
Tue, 17th Nov 2026 (Today)
McGrathNicol has published research showing more Australian businesses are paying ransomware demands. The survey found that 78 per cent of businesses hit by ransomware over the past five years paid a ransom.
The findings suggest a shift in behaviour even as the rate of successful breaches has fallen. Some 30 per cent of businesses reported a successful breach, down from 37 per cent a year earlier, but those that were compromised were more likely to transfer money and to do so sooner.
The consultancy worked with YouGov to survey 1,000 decision-makers at Australian businesses with 50 or more employees. It found that 69 per cent of respondents had experienced a ransomware attack in the past five years, while 42 per cent had faced one in the past 12 months.
Average ransom payments also rose. Businesses that paid handed over an average of AUD $794,000, up from AUD $711,000 in the previous survey, although the figure remained below earlier peaks.
Speed was another notable change. Among businesses that paid, 40 per cent did so within 24 hours, up 11 percentage points from the previous year.
Negotiation also appeared to play a smaller role. Two in five businesses that paid, or 41 per cent, did not negotiate before making a payment, up from 31 per cent in the earlier survey.
The research suggests willingness to pay remains widespread beyond businesses that have already faced an attack. Four in five respondents, or 84 per cent, said they would be willing to pay in at least some circumstances.
Prepared but pressured
That stance sits alongside evidence that many companies have formal cyber preparations in place. The survey found 93 per cent had cyber insurance, 81 per cent had incident response plans, and 88 per cent of business leaders considered their organisation prepared to respond to a cyber attack.
Even so, confidence has slipped. The share of business leaders who said they were prepared fell to 88 per cent from 96 per cent in the previous survey.
Awareness of regulatory obligations has also grown, with 71 per cent of business leaders familiar with Australia's ransomware payment reporting requirements.
In comments released with the findings, Darren Hopkins linked stronger preparedness with a continuing tendency to pay under pressure. "Our survey reveals a fundamental tension. Most Australian organisations have the plans, insurance and governance frameworks expected of a mature cyber resilience program, but those that suffer a ransomware attack are now more likely to pay," said Darren Hopkins, Partner & Head of Cyber at McGrathNicol.
"More attacked businesses chose to pay a cyber ransom in 2026 than in 2025, payments were made faster, and negotiation became less common than in previous years," Hopkins said.
He said planning documents alone did not resolve the problem. "We have seen significant improvement in incident response capabilities and levels of formal preparedness since 2021. But it's not enough to have an incident plan, framework or insurance policy sitting on your desk. Plans need to be regularly tested in real life simulations so that under pressure, everyone has the confidence to follow them," Hopkins said.
SME divide
The study points to a heavier burden on smaller businesses. While smaller organisations were not necessarily attacked more often, they were more than twice as likely as larger companies to suffer a successful breach.
Among organisations with revenue below $50 million, 38 per cent said they had been attacked and breached. That compared with 17 per cent of larger enterprises with revenue above $50 million.
Respondents also viewed smaller businesses as more exposed. Some 82 per cent of business leaders said SMEs were more vulnerable to ransomware than larger organisations.
The reasons cited most often were a lack of dedicated cyber security personnel, named by 37 per cent, limited technical expertise at 35 per cent, and constrained cyber security budgets, also at 35 per cent.
Those gaps can leave smaller companies struggling to manage incident response, forensics, legal issues, regulatory reporting and crisis communications at the same time. That can make payment appear to be the quickest route back to operations.
Brendan Payne, Cyber Partner at McGrathNicol, said those pressures cut across organisation size when disruption becomes serious. "When ransomware creates material operational or data risk, no matter the size of the organisation, executives face powerful pressures to pay," Payne said.
"The most effective resilience measure for SMEs is establishing trusted external support before an incident occurs. Organisations that know who to call, what information they need, and how they will recover will be better positioned to avoid rushed payment decisions," he said.
Common threats
The survey also asked about the motives behind payment decisions. The most common reason was to get back to normal operations faster, cited by 46 per cent of respondents, followed by re-establishing control of critical systems at 43 per cent and minimising harm to employees, customers and suppliers at 42 per cent.
That was consistent with the operational and financial damage reported by businesses that had been breached. Of those attacked in the past five years, 65 per cent said the incident had a significant or severe effect on IT systems, while 63 per cent reported a significant or severe effect on financial operations.
Phishing remained the most common cyber threat in the survey, affecting 44 per cent of businesses in the past 12 months. It was followed by business email compromise at 33 per cent, malware at 32 per cent, and the exploitation of unpatched vulnerabilities at 23 per cent.
Hopkins said many smaller companies still struggle to turn concern about cyber risk into practical action. "For SMEs, cyber security is often placed in the 'too hard basket'. Executives recognise that cyber risk is important but struggle to identify practical and achievable actions for their organisation. We see a continued focus on visible technology purchases rather than on broader governance and resilience activities," he said.